Bad Man, Bad Manager

Although morally good people do not necessarily make good managers, it does seem a universal truth that bad people make bad managers.

Their defects of character tend to come out in their management style.

To quote an extreme example, it was Adolf Hitler’s paranoia and megalomania that caused him to micro-manage military operations on the Eastern Front in World War Two – with disastrous results for his own side.

Field Marshal von Manstein, his best field commander, describes how it was sometimes impossible to move a single regiment, among hundreds, without approval from Berlin – but, at the same time, equally difficult to get a definite decision from about the general strategy of the campaign. Far from being a contradiction, this is a common flaw in micro-managers, who are too obsessed with individual trees to spend time considering the forest as a whole.

Micro-management is almost always a mistake. Even if there was perfect communication – and there never is – the man on the spot will always know more about what is happening on the ground than the man in the top floor office. That problem is made worse by the inevitable delays in getting a decision, as the decision-maker is busy with his other responsibilities, and as messages take hours, even days, to travel up and down the chain of command – during which time the whole situation may have changed.

The irony is that, through no merit of his own, Hitler had inherited an excellent professional officer class from the previous regimes which included some of the most talented soldiers in history – von Manstein, Kesselring, Rommel, Guderian, and Student, among many others.

These men were the product of a military tradition which – contrary to national stereotype – encouraged initiative on the part of subordinate leaders.

It is just as well for the rest of humanity that Hitler had did not know how to use them. He called himself the Fuhrer – “the Leader” – but the fact is that Hitler had no idea how to lead. He could not delegate. Unable to trust others, he was not trusted by his own senior executives. Too busy meddling with details, he neglected the real function of a leader: he failed to provide a clear sense of direction and strategy.

Today, an interfering, officious manager or bureaucrat who tries to cover his own inadequacies by ordering others about is often called a “little Hitler”. It is a fitting monument to the original.

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



Disclaimer/Copyright Privacy Integrity Promise





© Agincourt Productions