Faust v Mephistopheles (2010)

One of the wisest and most common pieces of advice in business is “Never sign anything without reading it”.

Or, better still, “Never sign anything without a good lawyer reading it.”

Yet we all do – all of us – all the time. We sign, initial, or, more and more frequently now, click all sorts of forms, receipts, waivers, disclaimers, and acceptances of standard terms and conditions, with barely a second glance.

We often have no idea what we are signing. For all we know we could be signing away our businesses, our homes, even our immortal souls.

That has in fact happened. As an April Fool’s ruse (but also to highlight the futility of such documents), an online game retailer inserted clause into its terms and conditions granting it ownership if the customer’s immortal soul. It now owns 7,500 of them!

So why are we all so stupid? Partly it is convenience. Is anyone really going to call his lawyer every time the postman is standing in front of him asking for a signature on a receipt for a package?

Partly it is necessity. We know perfectly well that, if we read standard terms and conditions properly, we would find them too favourable to the party who drafted them, and we would be unable to sign. So we sign without reading properly – because we want or need what is being offered too much, and we have no option but to sign if we are to get it. If there was a button marked “haggle”, we would click it, but we are given a straight choice between “I agree” and “I do not agree” – and to click the latter all the time might be prudent, but it would effectively exclude us from normal 21st Century life.

Mainly we sign because we assume that no one will take unfair advantage. This might sound naive, but, like most assumptions, it holds true more often than not.

Here is the Big Secret: standard terms and conditions are often of dubious value. Lawyers who draft them put in everything they can possibly imagine in order to cover themselves and protect their clients. However, courts – i.e. other lawyers – are well aware of this and take it into account. They often take a common sense approach rather than enforce the strict letter of the law. Certainly it is always worthwhile to challenge a strict interpretation of a standard form.

If you are negotiating a business deal, the important thing is to be clear on the main points and put them in a letter of understanding in plain English. That will be far more valuable than any standard form if there is ever any dispute.

Comments

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



Disclaimer/Copyright Privacy Integrity Promise





© Agincourt Productions